Indigo has been playing soccer for fourteen years; she played one year at St. Mary's Episcopal School and the remainder of her high school career at Central High. She also plays club soccer for the Memphis Rush. She was recently named Best Offensive player on her 2009 high school team. Indigo plays both defender and forward.

Indigo was being recruited by Mississippi College, University of Evansville, and Jackson State University. She chose Bethel because she felt that it was where she needed to be, and she felt welcome.