| | Day | Time | | Opponent | Score | | | Record |
| February |
| % | 17 | 1:00PM | vs. | Dyersburg State CC | W-12-5 | | | |
| % | | Game 2 | vs. | Dyersburg State CC | W-10-5 | | | |
| | 21 | 12:00PM | vs. | Campbellsville University | W-2-1 | stats | | 0-0 1-0 |
| | @ Martin Methodist, Pulaski, Tenn. |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Campbellsville University | W-9-3 | stats | | 0-0 2-0 |
| | 22 | 1:00PM | vs. | UVA-Wise | W-8-7 | stats | | 0-0 3-0 |
| | @ Martin Methodist, Pulaski, Tenn. |
| | | 3:00PM | vs. | Martin Methodist | L-0-2 | stats | | 0-0 3-1 |
| | MMC Spring Meltdown Tourney |
| | 25 | 1:00PM | vs. | Trevecca Nazarene University | W-4-0 | stats | | 0-0 4-1 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Trevecca Nazarene University | W-6-5 | stats | | 0-0 5-1 |
| | 27 | 1:00PM | vs. | Christian Brothers University | W-4-3 | stats | | 0-0 6-1 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Christian Brothers University | L-0-3 | stats | | 0-0 6-2 |
| March |
| * | 5 | 1:00PM | @ | Cumberland Univ. | W-10-0 (7) | stats | | 1-0 7-2 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Cumberland Univ. | W-14-1 (5) | stats | | 2-0 8-2 |
| | 6 | 3:00PM | vs. | Nova Southeastern University | L-0-3 | stats | | 2-0 8-3 |
| | Clark-Atlanta Tournament - Nova ranked #2 in NCAA D-II |
| | | 5:00PM | vs. | Clark Atlanta University | W-13-0 | stats | | 2-0 9-3 |
| | Clark Atlanta Tournament |
| | 7 | 9:00AM | vs. | Rollins College | L-0-5 | stats | | 2-0 9-4 |
| | Clark Atlanta Tournament - Rollins #7 NCAA D-II |
| | | 11:00AM | vs. | Paine College | W-14-0 | stats | | 2-0 10-4 |
| | Clark Atlanta Tournament |
| | 13 | 12:00PM | vs. | Davenport University | RAIN | | | |
| | Union Tournament - Jackson, TN |
| | | 2:00PM | vs. | Tennessee Wesleyan | RAIN | | | |
| | Union Tournament - Jackson, TN |
| | | 4:00PM | vs. | Georgetown College | RAIN | | | |
| | Union Tournament - Jackson, TN |
| | 14 | | @ | Union University | RAIN | | | |
| | Union Tournament - Jackson, TN |
| | | 5:00PM | vs. | TBA | RAIN | | | |
| | Union Tournament Championship Game - Jackson, TN |
| | 18 | 2:00PM | vs. | Lambuth University | W-4-3 | stats | | 2-0 11-4 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Lambuth University | W-7-4 | stats | | 2-0 12-4 |
| | 20 | 4:00PM | vs. | Lambuth University | W-3-2 (8) | stats | | 2-0 13-4 |
| | Bellhaven Tournament |
| | | 6:00PM | vs. | Thomas University | W-1-0 | stats | | 2-0 14-4 |
| | Bellhaven Tournament |
| | 21 | 11:00AM | vs. | Belhaven University | L-0-8 (5) | stats | | 2-0 14-5 |
| | Bellhaven Tournament |
| | | 3:00PM | vs. | William Woods University | W-8-1 | stats | | 2-0 15-5 |
| | William Woods #14 NAIA | Leah Hensley, Brittini Burlison & Kasey Winsett All-Tourney Team |
| | 23 | 1:00PM | @ | Fisk University | W-26-0 | stats | | 2-0 16-5 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Fisk University | W-21-1 | stats | | 2-0 17-5 |
| | 24 | 1:00PM | vs. | Central Baptist College | L-2-3 | stats | | 2-0 17-6 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Central Baptist College | W-4-0 | stats | | 2-0 18-6 |
| * | 26 | 3:00PM | @ | Trevecca Nazarene University | L-1-7 | stats | | 2-1 18-7 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Trevecca Nazarene University | L-3-4 (8) | stats | | 2-2 18-8 |
| * | 31 | 4:00PM | @ | Union University | RAIN | | | |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Union University | RAIN | | | |
| April |
| | 2 | 5:00PM | @ | Freed-Hardeman | RAIN | | | |
| | Rescheduled games from 3.02.09 |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Freed-Hardeman | RAIN | | | |
| | Rescheduled games from 3.02.09 |
| * | 7 | 1:00PM | vs. | Lyon College | W-4-1 | stats | | 3-2 19-8 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Lyon College | W-4-1 | stats | | 4-2 20-8 |
| | 8 | 1:00PM | vs. | Mid-Continent College | W-3-1 | stats | | 4-2 21-8 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Mid-Continent College | W-5-0 | stats | | 4-2 22-8 |
| * | 13 | Game 2 | @ | Union University | RAIN | | | |
| * | | 4:00PM | @ | Union University | RAIN | | | |
| * | 14 | 2:00PM | vs. | Martin Methodist | L-0-5 | stats | | 4-3 22-9 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Martin Methodist | L-2-4 | stats | | 4-4 22-10 |
| * | 15 | 3:00PM | @ | Mid-Continent College | W-7-0 | stats | | 5-4 23-10 |
| | Rescheduled from 3/28/09 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Mid-Continent College | W-7-0 | stats | | 6-4 24-10 |
| | Rescheduled from 3/28/09 |
| * | 17 | 2:00PM | vs. | Freed-Hardeman | W-4-3 | stats | | 7-4 25-10 |
| * | | Game 2 | vs. | Freed-Hardeman | L-2-5 | stats | | 7-5 25-11 |
| | 19 | 3:00PM | @ | Lambuth University | RAIN | | | |
| | | Game 2 | @ | Lambuth University | RAIN | | | |
| * | 20 | 2:00PM | @ | Union University | L-0-4 | stats | | 7-6 25-12 |
| * | | Game 2 | @ | Union University | W-1-0 | stats | | 8-6 26-12 |
| | 22 | 1:00PM | vs. | Fisk University | W-18-0 (5) | stats | | 8-6 27-12 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Fisk University | W-26-1 (5) | stats | | 8-6 28-12 |
| | 24 | 1:00PM | vs. | Cumberland Univ. | W-5-3 (9) | stats | | 8-6 29-12 |
| | | Game 2 | vs. | Cumberland Univ. | W-3-1 | stats | | 8-6 30-12 |
| | 29 | 10:00AM | vs. | Trevecca Nazarene University | W-4-1 | stats | | 8-6 31-12 |
| | Live Stats |
| | 30 | 1:00PM | @ | Martin Methodist | W-2-0 | stats | | 8-6 32-12 |
| | 2009 TranSouth Conference Tourney |
| May |
| | 1 | 1:00PM | vs. | Freed-Hardeman | W-2-1 | stats | | 8-6 33-12 |
| | Live Stats |
| | 2 | 3:00PM | vs. | TBA | RAIN | | | |
| | Bethel declared TranSouth Champions |
| | 14 | 11:30AM | vs. | Oklahoma City University | L-0-3 | | | 8-6 33-13 |
| | NAIA National Tournament | Pool Play | Decatur, Ala. |
| | 15 | 2:30PM | vs. | Simon Fraser University | L-2-6 (8) | | | 8-6 33-14 |
| | NAIA National Tournament | Pool Play | Decatur, Ala. |
| | 16 | 6:30PM | vs. | Georgetown College | RAIN | | | |
| | NAIA National Tournament | Pool Play | Decatur, Ala. |
| | 17 | 8:00PM | vs. | Georgetown College | W-5-4 | | | 8-6 34-14 |
| | NAIA National Tournament | Pool Play | Decatur, Ala. |